Are one of the reasons that these exhausts cost so much have to do with a built-in catalyst? I've heard that the muffler and catalyst are integrated..
Most aftermarket do not have a catalyst, many stock do. As for the Xciting 500, I do not know if the stock muffler has a catalyst or not, but am sure IT WEIGHS A TON. At this point, I am moving on to reworking a muffler from another machine of similar cylinder displacement size, so I am trolling ebay and craigslist. The X500 muffler is clamped, rather then welded, to the exhaust pipe so this would allow re-installation of the stock exhaust if needed.
The GPR for my Silver Wing was a slip-on but was designed to sit at almost a 45 degree upswept angle. I hated that and so cut off the inlet, changed the angle and welded it back on. I then made new mounts (above pic is after the modifications). Though I felt the GPR was too free flowing and a bit fragile, it was a fraction of the weight and improved the handling due to the weight loss.
The Silver Wing has a rigid mounted engine (more motorcycle like) so the suspension must move the weight of the tire, wheel, swingarm / transmission. The X500 engine is part of the suspension -- a pivoting engine system (more traditional scooter design). Thus when hitting a bump the rear suspension must move the weight of the engine, transmission, exhaust as well as wheel, tire, etc. the X500 engine and transmission are big, heavy-duty units (and used on Kymco, as well as other brands of ATVs) and consequently, very heavy. Swapping to a lighter exhaust can significantly improve the suspension reaction time, and thus the overall handling.
A long winded explanation that my motives are for power performance, as well as suspension performance.